Home Forums Blogs Articles Photos Videos Contact FAQ

Aristotle - Aristotle's epistemology

Aristotle - Aristotle's epistemology: Encyclopedia II - Aristotle - Aristotle's epistemology

Aristotle - Logic. Main articles: Aristotelian logic, and [[{{{2}}}]], and [[{{{3}}}]], and [[{{{4}}}]], and [[{{{5}}}]] For more details on this ...

Aristotle: Encyclopedia II - Aristotle - Aristotle's epistemology

Aristotle - Aristotle's epistemology

Aristotle - Logic

Main articles: Aristotelian logic, and [[{{{2}}}]], and [[{{{3}}}]], and [[{{{4}}}]], and [[{{{5}}}]] For more details on this topic, see Non-Aristotelian logic.

Aristotle "says that 'on the subject of reasoning' he 'had nothing else on an earlier date to speak about'" (Bocheński, 1951). However, Plato reports that syntax was thought of before him, by Prodikos of Keos, who was concerned by the right use of words. Logic seems to have emerged from dialectics; the earlier philosophers used concepts like reductio ad absurdum as a rule when discussing, but never understood its logical implications. Even Plato had difficulties with logic. Although he had the idea of constructing a system for deduction, he was never able to construct one. Instead, he relied on his dialectic, which was a confusion between different sciences and methods (Bocheński, 1951). Plato thought that deduction would simply follow from premises, so he focused on having good premises so that the conclusion would follow. Later on, Plato realised that a method for obtaining the conclusion would be beneficial. Plato never obtained such a method, but his best attempt was published in his book Sophist, where he introduced his division method (Rose, 1968).

What we call today Aristotelian logic, Aristotle himself would have labelled analytics. The term logic he reserved to mean dialectics. Most of Aristotle's work is probably not authentic, since it was most likely edited by students and later lecturers. The logical works of Aristotle were compiled into six books at about the time of Christ:

Categories
On Interpretation
Prior Analytics
Posterior Analytics
Topics
On Sophistical Refutations

The order of the books (or the teachings from which they are composed) is not certain, but this list was derived from analysis of Aristotle's writings. There is one volume of Aristotle's concerning logic not found in the Organon, namely the fourth book of Metaphysics. (Bocheński, 1951).

Aristotle is also the creator of syllogisms with modalities (modal logic). The word modal refers to the word 'modes', explaining the fact that modal logic deals with the modes of truth. Aristotle introduced the qualification of 'necessary' and 'possible' premises. He constructed a logic which helped in the evaluation of truth but which was very difficult to interpret. (Rose, 1968).

Aristotle - Science

Aristotelian discussions about science had only been qualitative, not quantitative. By the modern definition of the term, Aristotelian philosophy was not science, as this worldview did not attempt to probe how the world actually worked through experiment. For example, in his book The history of animals he claimed that human males have more teeth than females. Had he only made some observations, he would have discovered that this claim is false.

Rather, based on what one's senses told one, Aristotelian philosophy then depended upon the assumption that man's mind could elucidate all the laws of the universe, based on simple observation (without experimentation) through reason alone.

One of the reasons for this was that Aristotle held that physics was about changing objects with a reality of their own, whereas mathematics was about unchanging objects without a reality of their own. In this philosophy, he could not imagine that there was a relationship between them.

In contrast, today's "science" assumes that thinking alone often leads people astray, and therefore one must compare one's ideas to the actual world through experimentation; only then can one see if one's ideas are based in reality. This position is known as empiricism or the scientific method.

Other related archives

12th century, 13th century, 15th century, 1951, 1968, 2004, 322 BC, 335 BC, 340s BC, 344 BC, 347 BC, 384 BC, 60 BC, 86 BC, Academy, Alexander the Great, Amyntas III of Macedon, Analytic, Anaxagoras, Ancient philosophy, Andronicus of Rhodes, Andros, Apellicon of Teos, Apollo Lyceios, Aristoteles crater, Aristotelian ethics, Aristotelian logic, Aristotelian theory of gravity, Aristotelian view of God, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Aristotle's theory of universals, Asia Minor, Athens, Aulus Gellius, Avicenna, Bekker numbers, Bertrand Russell, Callisthenes, Categories, Chalcidice, Chalcis, Christ, Christian, Cockney rhyming slang, Constitution of the Athenians, Corpus Aristotelicum, De Anima, Dialogues, Diogenes, Efficient Cause, Endoxa, Epicureans, Euboea, Eudemian Ethics, Farabi, Final Cause, Formal Cause, Galileo, Golden Age of Islam, Gorgias, Great Ethics, Greek, Greek philosophy, Gregory Nazianzen, Harpalus, Harvard University, Hephaestion, Hermias, History of Animals, J. Arthur Rank, John Philoponus, Jonathan Barnes, Justin Martyr, Kantian, Lamian war, Lesbos, Loeb Classical Library, Logic, Lyceum, Macedonian, March 7, Material Cause, Mathematics, Mechanical Problems, Melissus, Metaphysics, Meteorology, Middle Ages, Moon, Mytilene, Nicolaus of Damascus, Nicomachean Ethics, Nicomachus, Non-Aristotelian logic, On Dreams, On Generation and Corruption, On Interpretation, On Longevity and Shortness of Life, On Memory and Reminiscence, On Prophesying by Dreams, On Sense and the Sensible, On Sleep and Sleeplessness, On Sophistical Refutations, On the Cosmos, On the Gait of Animals, On the Generation of Animals, On the Heavens, On the Parts of Animals, On the Soul, Organon, Oxford Classical Texts, Oxford University, Parallel Lives, Peripatetic, Philip II of Macedon, Philosophy, Physics, Plato, Platonism, Platonists, Pliny, Plutarch, Poetics, Politics, Posterior Analytics, Presocratic, Princeton University, Prior Analytics, Rhetoric, Rome, Scholastic, Socrates, Stageira, Strabo, Straton, Sulla, The history of animals, Theophrastus, Topics, Truth, Western, Western philosophy, Xenocrates, Xenophanes, abstract, aesthetics, anatomy, ancient Greek, ancient Greek philosophers, artifact, astrological, astronomy, behaving, biology, causes, colony, conclusion, deduction, deductive, deficiency, dialectic, dialectics, didactic, dogma, economics, education, embryology, empirical, empiricism, empiricists, encyclopedia, epistemology, essence, ethics, excess, exemplar, experiment, fifth century, genera, geography, geology, gods, goodness, government, gravity, gymnasium, happiness, hemlock, heretics, idea, impiety, impulse, inductive, innate, laws of physics, light, literature, logic, magical, mass, materialism, mathematician, medicine, metaphysics, meteorology, middle ages, modal logic, motion, orphan, particular, phenomena, philosopher, philosophy, physics, poetry, politics, premises, prototype, psychology, reason, reasoning, reductio ad absurdum, rhetoric, scientific method, skeptical, soul, syllogisms, syntax, systematic, telos, theology, theoretical, tides, treatise, truth, universal, virtue, virtues, worldview, zoology

Adapted from the Wikipedia article "Aristotle's epistemology", under the G.N U Free Docmentation License. Please also see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki

More material related to Aristotle can be found here:

Main Page
for
Aristotle Index of Articles
related to
Aristotle Glossary
related to
Aristotle